Rome prosecutor's office: hypotheses of torture and sexual violence
Magistrates from piazzale Clodio have already begun questioning Italian activists, with Five Star Movement (M5S) MP Dario Carotenuto questioned first. Investigators are analyzing a video published on social media on Wednesday by Israeli Minister Ben-Gvir — showing kneeling activists with bound hands and bowed heads in the port of Ashdod. It is being assessed whether Italian citizens were among them and whether Ben-Gvir's conduct could form part of the basis for a criminal assessment. ANSA ↗The Flotilla's legal team announced the same day that it is gathering testimonies from the returned Italian activists and will file a supplement to the submission of May 19 — a denuncia per tortura, a formal report on suspicion of the crime of torture. ANSA ↗
Flotilla spokeswoman Maria Elena Delia told ANSA that approximately fifty participants are hospitalized in Istanbul, including one Italian. "Many suffered serious injuries, some are in shock," she said. According to a quick count relayed by El País, the Flotilla's doctor tallied at least 35 rib fractures and more than ten reports of sexual violence among the detainees from just the first intercepted vessel. MP Carotenuto mentioned in an interview with El País that the sister of the Irish president, Margaret Connolly, a nurse, coordinated first aid for twenty to thirty people with fractures and also recorded some claims of sexual abuse. The figures come from testimonies by activists and Flotilla doctors; independent confirmation from hospitals is not yet available. El Pais ↗
Tajani demands sanctions, Schlein targets the trade agreement
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani of Forza Italia announced on X on Thursday that "on behalf of the Italian government" he is formally asking EU High Representative Kaja Kallas to place on the agenda of the next meeting of EU foreign ministers the adoption of sanctions against Ben-Gvir for the unacceptable acts he committed against the Flotilla — detaining activists in international waters and subjecting them to attacks and humiliation, thereby violating the most basic human rights. For the government of Giorgia Meloni, which has long blocked anti-Israel measures in the EU Council, this represents a significant shift. La Repubblica ↗Democratic Party (PD) leader Elly Schlein points to a politically significant detail. "Ben Gvir is not an exception to the Israeli government, he is the rule," she said at an economic festival in Trento. According to her, sanctions against a specific Israeli minister require unanimity in the EU Council, which countries such as Hungary or Slovakia would block. "However, unanimity is not required to approve trade sanctions — a qualified majority is sufficient." Schlein is therefore calling for the removal of Italy's veto on suspending the trade parts of the EU–Israel agreement. La Repubblica ↗
Politico Europe confirms that pressure for sanctions is growing elsewhere too — Spain has already banned Ben-Gvir from entering the country in previous months, and Germany is reconsidering its previous resistance to punitive measures against Israeli officials. Politico Europe ↗
What is new compared to Slovak coverage
Slovak media covered the interception of the Flotilla and its deportation via agency sources. Aktuality.sk also carried the reaction of Foreign Minister Juraj Blanár from May 21: "I consider such conduct unacceptable and contrary to the basic principles of human dignity." According to him, the Slovak embassy in Israel requested an immediate consular visit to Slovak citizen Dáša Raimanová. aktuality.sk ↗Slovak coverage, however, is missing three layers that dominate the Italian discussion. First, the criminal-law dimension — the Rome prosecutor's office is already formally examining allegations of torture and sexual violence. Second, the shift of the Italian right — Tajani of Forza Italia, part of Giorgia Meloni's government which has historically been friendly toward Netanyahu, is for the first time asking the EU for sanctions against an Israeli minister. Third, political arithmetic — Schlein's argument about a qualified majority for trade sanctions suggests that Tajani's proposed sanctions against Ben-Gvir (requiring unanimity) could be blocked by Hungary or Slovakia, whereas under a qualified majority, Slovakia alone would not be able to block it. This is relevant for a Slovak reader — the question is likely to be put to Blanár at the next EU Council meeting as well.
Read also: Israel intercepted the entire Sumud Flotilla. Berlin questions its legality, Schlein demands sanctions
Limits of the Italian perspective
La Repubblica belongs to the liberal center-left segment of newspapers and is close to the PD; it can be rhetorically sympathetic when reporting Schlein's statements. ANSA, as a wire agency, is more neutral, but even its phrasing "reati di tortura e violenza sessuale" sounds more categorical than the formal state of affairs: the prosecutor's office is so far examining these crimes, it has not brought charges. Given the weight of such allegations, it is reasonable to wait for a ruling from the Italian court rather than read newspaper phrasing as a verdict.Britain's Guardian adds broader context that the Italian discussion bypasses. Ben-Gvir has a years-long record of publishing similar videos from Israeli prisons, where the victims are Palestinian prisoners. Human rights organizations have for years described these as sites of systematic torture. Global attention arrived only once the target of humiliation in the video became 400 foreign activists. The point of the Guardian's analysis is that sanctions against Ben-Gvir will show whether Western states are responding to the act itself or only to the nationality of the victims. The Guardian ↗
What hotinfo is watching
- The next meeting of EU foreign ministers (FAC): Will Kaja Kallas put Tajani's proposed sanctions against Ben-Gvir on the agenda? Who will oppose it — Hungary, Slovakia, or other states?
- Slovakia's position at the FAC: Blanár's statement from May 21 was strong, but Bratislava has so far voted with Budapest against anti-Israel measures in the EU Council. What position will it take this time?
- Conclusions of the Rome prosecutor's office: When and with what conclusion will it close its examination of the suspicions of torture and sexual violence? Will it charge specific Israeli soldiers?
- The condition of the fifty hospitalized in Istanbul and the number of activists who will give formal testimony to Italian, Irish, or Spanish police.







