The Italian Foreign Ministry received assurances that 29 Italian citizens should return home on Wednesday, May 20. The opposition, led by Democratic Party leader Elly Schlein, is demanding that Giorgia Meloni’s government impose sanctions on Israel. La Repubblica ↗
The operation in international waters roughly 250 nautical miles (463 kilometers) from the coast of Gaza also triggered a significant diplomatic response in Berlin. Germany joined other EU member states that, according to the German press agency dpa, have openly questioned the legality of the interception. Die Zeit ↗
Second day of boarding ships: the last vessels and fire with non-lethal means
The operation began on Monday, May 18, at 10:30 Cyprus time, when Israeli commandos boarded the first ship, Furleto, in the initiative’s live stream, which showed activists raising their hands and putting on life jackets. BBC ↗On Tuesday during the day, Israeli soldiers gradually entered additional vessels — Andros, Zefiro, Alcyone, Ksar Sadabad, Girolama, and the ship don Juan. The crew of the Italian Girolama shouted in videos from the deck: “Why are you shooting? We are unarmed.” La Repubblica wrote about rubber bullets; shots could be heard in the videos before soldiers boarded the vessel. La Repubblica ↗
Italian flotilla spokesperson Maria Elena Delia said the crew could not tell whether live or rubber bullets were used, and called the operation a “serious crime.” The Israeli army responded on Tuesday evening with a statement saying that at no point had it used live fire — “non-lethal means were used against the vessel, not against the protesters, as a warning. None of the protesters was injured.” ANSA ↗
The word “sumud” in the name means perseverance or steadfastness in Arabic — in the Palestinian political vocabulary, it is used as a term for resilience against occupation. The flotilla, with 54 ships and more than 460 activists, set sail on Thursday, May 14, from the Turkish port of Marmaris after the Israeli army intercepted a first attempt near Crete at the end of April. BBC ↗
Who is among the detained: activists from 40 countries
The largest group consists of Turks (about 75), followed by Spaniards (33), French citizens (29), and Italians (29). Among those detained are also activists from Chile, Argentina, Mexico, and Brazil. El Pais ↗Slovak citizen Dáša Raimanová was traveling, according to the initiative’s website, on the ship Furleto. She had informed about her participation on Instagram in the previous days. Among the detained Italians are M5S (Five Star Movement) MP Dario Carotenuto, Il Fatto Quotidiano journalist Alessandro Mantovani, trade union leader Dario Salvetti from the former Gkn factory, and former candidate for governor of Tuscany Antonella Bundu. La Repubblica ↗
Also detained are 11 named Australians — including doctor Bianca Pullman-Webb, documentary filmmaker Juliet Lamont, and activist Violet Coco — three Poles, six Dutch citizens, and at least six Irish citizens, including Margaret Connolly, sister of Irish President Catherine Connolly. Among the Spanish detainees is El País journalist Ignacio Ladrón de Guevara. The Guardian ↗
Irish President Catherine Connolly said after meeting Britain’s King Charles III in London that she had not yet spoken with her sister. “I am very proud of my sister, but I am worried about her.” Prime Minister Micheál Martin called the operation “absolutely unacceptable.” BBC ↗
Tajani against Schlein — political clash in Rome
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani spoke directly on Tuesday evening with Israel’s ambassador to Italy, and according to La Repubblica, the Farnesina received assurances that Italian citizens would return home on Wednesday, May 20. Earlier that same day, Tajani asked Israeli authorities “for an urgent verification of the use of force” against civilian vessels. La Repubblica ↗The Italian opposition called the government’s response insufficient. Democratic Party leader Elly Schlein urged the government: “Let the government finally speak up.” The Democrats, together with the Greens and Left Alliance and M5S, demanded that Rome call for the immediate release of all activists and consider sanctions against Israel. Schlein added a remark aimed at Prime Minister Meloni’s League allies: “Where are the sovereignists when Italian citizens are abducted?” La Repubblica ↗
Diplomatic wave and Berlin’s position
Spanish Foreign Minister José Manuel Albares on Monday summoned Israeli embassy envoy Dana Erlich in Madrid to convey a “formal and forceful protest” over a “new violation of international law.” El Mundo ↗Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan described the operation as “piracy and banditry” against “travelers of hope.” BBC ↗
Germany’s reaction is notable given its traditionally cautious stance. Germany is among the European states that have long emphasized Israel’s security, but according to dpa it has joined several EU states questioning the compatibility of the intervention in international waters with international law. Tagesspiegel ↗
Israel defends the operation
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday praised the navy commander by phone, saying the soldiers “are doing exceptional work” and “effectively thwarted the sinister plan to break the isolation we are applying against the Hamas terrorists in Gaza.” In the same exchange, he said: “You are doing it with great success and, I must say, also discreetly, certainly less ostentatiously than our enemies expected. The water looks beautiful. I would like to be with you.” ANSA ↗Israel’s Foreign Ministry described the flotilla as a “provocation for the sake of provocation” with no humanitarian aid on board. It claims that the Turkish organization IHH, linked to the 2010 Mavi Marmara flotilla, is connected to the mission, and labels it terrorist. After the operation ended, Israel called the flotilla another “PR stunt in the service of Hamas.” BBC ↗
The organizers reject these claims and say the ships are carrying hundreds to thousands of kilograms of humanitarian aid. To their own call for the activists’ release they also added a request for the liberation of “more than 9,000 unjustly detained Palestinian political prisoners,” thus framing their cause as part of a broader struggle for Palestinian rights. Die Zeit ↗
Public reaction: railway station blockade in the Netherlands
On Tuesday evening, about 25 activists from Extinction Rebellion blocked the tracks at the main Den Haag Centraal station in solidarity with the flotilla. Five activists went directly onto the tracks, and train traffic to and from The Hague stopped for about an hour. They demanded that the Dutch government take measures in support of the detained activists and Palestinian civilians in Gaza. NOS ↗The shadow of Mavi Marmara 2010
Israel’s reference to IHH carries serious historical weight. In 2010, Israeli commandos attacked the Turkish vessel Mavi Marmara, part of that period’s humanitarian flotilla, which was co-organized precisely by IHH. Ten Turkish activists died during the boarding of the ship, triggering a long-running diplomatic crisis between Israel and Turkey. BBC ↗International waters — the legal dimension
According to The Guardian, Cypriot authorities confirmed that the operation took place outside their territorial waters and without prior notification. The Guardian ↗According to La Repubblica, the detained activists are to end up on a “prison ship” and then in the Israeli port of Ashdod, where a fast-track deportation procedure approved by the Israeli government at the end of March specifically for flotilla participants is likely to be applied — expulsion within 24 hours instead of the standard three days. Participants in the previous action also received a 99-year ban on entering Israel. La Repubblica ↗
In the previous action at the end of April, when Israel intercepted 22 ships of the same initiative near Crete, it released almost all 175 detainees the next day after international pressure. Only two — Spanish-Palestinian citizen Saíf Abu Keshk and Brazilian Thiago Ávila — were taken to Israel, where they spent 10 days in a prison in Ashkelon and were deported on May 10. Die Zeit ↗
Spokesperson Delia warned on Tuesday that the message of the operation goes beyond the flotilla itself. “The only thing that scares us now is not what is happening to us, but the world that is being built.” La Repubblica ↗
What hotinfo is watching
- Protests in Italy, Spain, Ireland or Turkey along the lines of XR in The Hague
- The EU responds formally as a bloc (not just individual states)
- Cyprus files a position on the operation in its EEZ, or the activists go to ITLOS
- Erdoğan escalates bilaterally against Israel (sanctions or recalling the ambassador)
- Twenty-nine Italians returned home on May 20, per assurances from the Farnesina→ Rím posudzuje podozrenia z mučenia aktivistov Sumud Flotilly. Tajani žiada sank…Talianski aktivisti vrátení do Ríma 21.5., Carotenuto a Mantovani prvý let cez Atény; ostatní cez Istanbul. ANSA + La Repubblica.
- The Slovak citizen Dáša Raimanová deported or released→ Rím posudzuje podozrenia z mučenia aktivistov Sumud Flotilly. Tajani žiada sank…aktuality.sk 21.5.: Izrael deportoval všetkých aktivistov vrátane Slovenky. Blanár potvrdzuje konzulárna komunikácia.
- The Slovak or Czech foreign ministry speaks publicly about the detained citizens→ Rím posudzuje podozrenia z mučenia aktivistov Sumud Flotilly. Tajani žiada sank…Juraj Blanár 21.5. cez aktuality.sk: konanie neprijateľné, v rozpore so základnými princípmi ľudskej dôstojnosti. SR veľvyslanectvo požiadalo o okamžitú konzulárnu návštevu.







